Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kate Voges's avatar

James, this is THE most important article I have ever read on relationships between women and men in my entire life of 88 years on this earth. Thank you.

Hilary Silver's avatar

James, I appreciate the accountability you’re asking men to take here. I’d push the question for women further, though, because even “What am I becoming when I’m with him?” keeps him as the reference point for understanding herself.

I would ask every woman: who are YOU, and are you being true to yourself? With a man or without one, in an evening gown, a bikini, or sweats, I want a woman to have a relationship with herself that goes deeper than how she is being perceived or experienced by somebody else. What she values, desires, believes, and chooses deserves her attention independently of whether a man is present to respond to it.

Of course relationships affect us, and each person is responsible for how they treat the other. For me, this means developing an internal point of reference from which you can recognize that influence and decide what you want to do about it. You can grow, reconsider, and change while remaining the person who determines what is true for you.

I want women asking whether the relationship makes room for who they are, with a genuine understanding of who that woman is. A man can matter enormously in your life without becoming the fucking measure of it.

Excellent article!

4 more comments...

Ready for more?