I recently read a wonderful essay by Feminist Lens, about what women should be aware of when dating men and particularly the idea that women increasingly have the freedom to choose a man because of who he is rather than because they need what he can provide. For those interestd, her article is here:
With her readers she created a list of red flags as important things to look out for and whilst reading them I found myself wanting to turn the whole thing around and ask men a different question.
What would a woman experience if she dated you?
Not what kind of man do you think you are but what is it actually like to love you and/or live with you?
I find that question uncomfortable because for much of my life there would have been an enormous difference between the answers I would have given to that question and the answers the women who were in my life at the time would have given.
Undoubtedly I would have told you that I was loving, loyal, generous, supportive, fun, romantic and a lovely man to be with and I’d have genuinely believed all of those things were true.
However, I equally undoubtedly suspect that the mother of my children and the woman I was in my longest ever relationship with would have told you that she increasingly thought about how to say something to me before saying it. That sometimes it was easier not to say something at all. That I often meant what I said but was less often able to follow through with it, which I now recognise as my intention regularly mattering more than her experience of me and that when she told me something I’d done had hurt her, there was every chance the conversation would somehow end up with her reassuring me that I wasn’t a bad man.
We wouldn’t even have been describing the same relationship at times. I wonder how many women recognise these patterns and experiences?
That’s what interests me about Zulfina’s list of questions because most of us men don’t walk around consciously believing that we’re one of men that that list refers to or even, if I’m brutally honest, we wouldn’t have even been aware that there was such a list, never mind considering whether or not we were on it.
Perhaps one of the questions we should ask about a relationship isn’t simply whether he treats her well but what starts happening to her in order for the relationship to keep working?
So here is a list of questions I have devised, entirely inspired by The Feminist Lens’ article, for men to ask themselves but that can also be asked by the women they are with too. My hope is that they may form a conversation between you both at some stage or become a deeper consideration for you both look to the future.
For the man, you won’t know the answer to all of these questions without asking your partner. If it matters to you enough to ask her then I trust that you will ask her to be honest with you, that you’ll listen to her answer and that you’ll be curious about her answers rather than defensive or aggressive. I’ve written them for you to ask yourself.
· Does she become more of her true self or gradually less as a result of being with me?
· Does she start rehearsing how to have potentially awkward conversations with me or have to start softening what she really thinks because experience has taught her that I’ll react defensively or aggressively?
· Does she stop mentioning certain things because they’re simply not worth the argument anymore because I won’t believe that she’s right about me?
· Does she become responsible for anticipating my moods, reassuring my insecurity or making sure her success doesn’t somehow make me feel less successful?
Now, none of those things necessarily arrive wearing a badge saying RED FLAG because they can arrive looking remarkably like compromise, patience, understanding and love, which is why I wonder whether men need our own version of the red flag conversation.
Not “what should I look out for in women?” but what happens to women when they spend enough time with me? For example:
1. Do the women I love become freer around me or more careful?
2. Can the women I love disagree with me without paying an emotional price afterwards?
3. Can the women I love tell me no and trust me with whatever disappointment that creates in me?
4. Can the women I love become more successful without needing to make themselves smaller so I can continue feeling big?
5. Can the women I love tell me something about myself that I desperately don’t want to hear and trust me not to make them regret telling me?
6. Can the women I love have a life that doesn’t revolve around me without me experiencing their independence as rejection?
7. When the women I love are unhappy, can I stay beside them without believing I need to fix them simply because I can’t tolerate what their unhappiness creates in me?
Those questions feel considerably more useful to me than asking whether I’m a good man because of course I’m going to want to believe that I am.
Our challenge as men is to move beyond the chronic desire of wanting to believe we’re a great guy to be with and instead, being courageous enough to ask our partner how we are being experienced.
It is then being willing to do something about it if the answer isn’t exactly as we hoped it would be because she loves us and she wants to be with us.
There’s something else we should consider as men too and it is this:
The woman experiencing us will almost certainly know us far better than we know ourselves, more honestly than we are with ourselves and have considerably more useful information for us to help us become that better man we dream of being and want to believe we are. In fact she’s probably been trying to tell us that for a long time and has given up.
That’s often one of the main reasons they leave us as we look around feeling lost and bewildered because “they never told me how I should have been” or “I never knew” which usually means I never listened so they learned to stop asking, sharing or telling me and eventually they gave up and left.
This matters more now because the relationship proposition has changed.
Increasing numbers of women no longer need a man in the way women were once forced or required to need us, which I personally think is wonderful news for men even though some don’t seem to have realised it yet and are still in full resistance mode!
If she no longer needs me to survive, provide a bank account, give her social legitimacy or make her life economically possible, I now get the opportunity to discover whether she actually wants me, for me, which can be anywhere between utterly terrifying or the most gloriously empowering feeling in the world.
Now, whilst this raises the bar considerably for how I get to show up and how much of the real, true and whole me I show up with, I also think it makes love infinitely more meaningful.
I spent most of my life needing to be needed because being needed made me feel worthy, wanted and thus loved, none of which I grew up feeling or believing about myself, chronic insecurity will do that to a person.
One of my greatest challenges, which will sound absurd when you think about it, has been to learn how to be loved and to accept that I am indeed, lovable…that I am indeed worthy of love as me rather than only because of what I can do or provide for others. That is major unlearning for the majority of men brought up within the patriarchy.
There’s another side to this though and it’s the one I kept coming back to because Zulfina wasn’t writing her essay for men like me. She was responding to women asking what they should be aware of when dating us.
Perhaps one of the most useful things a woman can notice isn’t simply what he does but what starts happening to her while she’s with him.
Not so she can diagnose him (you could), fix him (you absolutely can’t) or become even better at adapting herself around him (you’re probably an expert at this already) because God knows women have been asked to do enough of that already but just to start noticing what happens once she’s in a relationship with him.
I’ve written these as though I’m asking them to you, the woman:
¨Do you feel increasingly free to say what you actually think or are you beginning to think about how to say it before you do?
¨Do you still disagree as freely as you did at the beginning or have you discovered there are certain subjects that simply aren’t worth raising because they come with consequences?
¨Are you still seeing your friends and family as much as you want to and did?
¨Do you feel more ambitious around him or have you started making your successes slightly smaller because something changes in him when you shine?
¨When you’re unhappy, can you simply be unhappy or do you find yourself reassuring him that it isn’t his fault?
¨Can you tell him he’s hurt or upset you and remain the person being comforted?
¨Can you say no without immediately becoming responsible for what your no makes him feel?
¨Are you becoming more completely yourself or are there tiny parts of you disappearing so gradually that neither of you has really noticed them going?
I think that’s important because adaptation rarely announces itself as adaptation while we’re doing it. It can feel like compromise or like being understanding. It can feel like choosing your battles and it can even feel like love.
Again, this is familiar territory for me because I spent years being loved by a woman who adapted herself around parts of me that I couldn’t yet see whilst I continued believing I was loving her well.
She eventually stopped. She’s never stopped loving me but she did stop compromising and she was the one of us with the courage to recognise that we were no longer capable of being happy with each other and she left.
For my part, I will never stop loving her either and our lives, now as best friends and co-parents to our children, will always be entwined. She is still a huge part of my life, growth and development and I hope I am of hers, which is something I am so very happy about and proud of for both of us. The children get the very best of both worlds too, which is something I really wish parents who part would make their priority.
So perhaps alongside all the red flags and green flags and everything else we’ve created to help women navigate dating, there are two much simpler questions worth carrying with us.
For men:
What is it actually like to love me?
Not what do I provide or what do I intend, nor whether I think I’m a good man or not but what actually happens to the woman I love when she spends years experiencing me?
Does her life become smaller or does she become more completely herself?
Then perhaps for women there is an equally important question:
What am I becoming when I’m with him?
Not simply do I love him and not simply does he love me but:
Who am I becoming in order for us to work?
Because perhaps one of the clearest signs that you’re with somebody secure isn’t that you never disagree, never hurt each other or never get anything wrong. It’s that loving them doesn’t require you to become less of yourself or having to constantly do more to prove yourself in order to remain loved.
Surely that’s something worth noticing long before either of you has to lose yourselves to discover it.
With love,
James



James, this is THE most important article I have ever read on relationships between women and men in my entire life of 88 years on this earth. Thank you.
James, I appreciate the accountability you’re asking men to take here. I’d push the question for women further, though, because even “What am I becoming when I’m with him?” keeps him as the reference point for understanding herself.
I would ask every woman: who are YOU, and are you being true to yourself? With a man or without one, in an evening gown, a bikini, or sweats, I want a woman to have a relationship with herself that goes deeper than how she is being perceived or experienced by somebody else. What she values, desires, believes, and chooses deserves her attention independently of whether a man is present to respond to it.
Of course relationships affect us, and each person is responsible for how they treat the other. For me, this means developing an internal point of reference from which you can recognize that influence and decide what you want to do about it. You can grow, reconsider, and change while remaining the person who determines what is true for you.
I want women asking whether the relationship makes room for who they are, with a genuine understanding of who that woman is. A man can matter enormously in your life without becoming the fucking measure of it.
Excellent article!